Jedi Master Thrash said:
Is it due to lack of direct sega news and enthusiam?
Or is it due to whatever this mysterious drama from N years ago was (which nobody will explain to me)?
Well, Sega is producing a lot of games. In fact they cranked out (developed, published or both) 30 games last year. The Conduit and Madworld are probably the most hyped games for '09 for the Wii. Since they aren't on a Sega console, it's lost some of its mystique.
Honestly, I think the lack of enthusiasm is directly linked to the lack of Sega hardware. Maybe its just me, but this was always a sega hardware site, not software.
The mysterious drama isn't all that dramatic. There were multiple dramas, if I recall. As falstaff alluded to, there were some personality clashes. Then there was a schism between vgrebirth.org and here (something to do with hosting games). Then the site was compromised, repeatedly. The schism and one of the compromises happened at the same time, but the two were unrelated (even though it seemed so at the time). I personally disappeared right after this for a year or so, so if anything happened in the meantime, so one else will need to fill in the gaps.
The only major dramatic thing anyone really needs to know is that dibz posted a message stating that segaxtreme was going to disappear, and then a ton of people came out of the woodwork and donated money to keep it running. SX isn't going anywhere, even if it's quiet on the boards.
---
As JMT said, we have a ton of content. Feeds from various sites would be pretty cool, if only for us to comment on. Organizing all the content is a monumental task, and without some concerted effort it'd be too hard for one, two or even five people.
I don't know what happened to vgrebirth's forums, I can't access them. Racketboy's site is powered by sheer will - he writes a lot of content and gets them up on social networks, and he posts profusely on his site. Seganerds.com's forums and irc... well, sega nerds has a lot of news postings, but the quality of posts there are the exact opposite of here.
I guess, there's pitfalls for all these things.