You also asked what didn't sell you on the saturn, so I'll tell why for me. I was a big sega fan already and was quite happy with the sega cd and genesis. But after getting the 32x I really lost alot of faith in Sega.
I didn't get a playstation, but my brother did, and I can certainly say the first generation games on psx wiped the floor with their saturn equivelants, at least graphically (and in gameplay in my opinion). Just look at Virtua Fighter vs Tekken or Toshinden or Daytona vs Ridge Racer. I wasn't anti Saturn, but had no particular need to buy one. A few years later my friend went to europe for a few months and I borrowed his Saturn while he was gone, along with several games. At Toys R Us I saw Shining Force 3 for $20. Never played an SF game, but I knew it was one of the last Saturn games and the price was right, so what the hell. Love that game, and it was so good I bought my own Saturn to play it, as well as to get Scenario 2 and 3, the first import games I ever bought.