• Rise from your gwave!

Damaged Rars >_<

Discussion in 'General Tech Help & CD Burning Help' started by Redglow, Mar 6, 2002.

  1. Redglow

    Redglow New Member

    I just downloaded Burning Rangers and 4 of the rar files are damaged. I was wondering what I do to fix this. Do I have to download them again? If so will it work if I get them from the same FTP? Thanks
     
  2. archiver

    archiver New Member

    Corrupt rars can't be fixed/salvaged like .zips, sorry.

    Yes, you will need to download the files again; however you might consider privately contacting who's hosting them to see if they can verify if source files are corrupt.

    (Edited by archiver at 5:02 pm on Mar. 6, 2002)
     
  3. mal

    mal Member

    That's not necessarily true. If the person making the archive included a recovery record it may be possible to repair the corrupt files.

    Just don't bank on it.
     
  4. Shinji

    Shinji New Member

    The recovery record will only work if there are more then on file in the archive. With only one file, like in bin/cue rips (ok, don't mind the cue file here) it's nearly useless.

    And Burning Rangers is a bin/cue rip AFAIK.

    (Edited by Shinji at 12:14 pm on Mar. 7, 2002)
     
  5. mal

    mal Member

    To quote the WinRAR help file

    This says to me that if a RAR archive has a recovery record and the damage is not too bad, then recovery is possible.

    This seems to idicate, as you say Shinji, that if the damage is severe, that recovery of corrupted files is impossible, but undamaged ones are recoverable. Not much use with bin/cues.

    Like I said, it might be recoverable.

    It depends on the damage and the presence of a recovery record.
     
  6. archiver

    archiver New Member

    ...and whether the archive is solid or not, as mentioned.

    Adding recovery records (dependent on the % the user sets them to) can add to the file size. Because it can't be a solid archive, it usually means for a lesser compression ratio, again adding to file size.

    What I do, right after solid raring, I zip them in store format. Before I burn to disc/do any online transfers, I do a scan of the zips' CRCs.

    For multiple file (rar or zip) compressing/decompressing, I use RomZipper (with the v1.35b2 update):

    http://www.smiff.clara.net/utils/rom.htm

    To scan drives/folders for zip file integrity, I use CFAtest:

    http://cfa.skuz.net/cfa2.htm
     
  7. ExCyber

    ExCyber Staff Member

    Please do NOT compress BIN/CUE as a solid archive. It's completely useless due to the relative sizes of the image and cuesheet - all it accomplishes is making the archive more difficult to deal with. Solid archiving is good for archives with lots of small files, not for massive chunks of data like full CD images. If you don't believe me, try doing a comparison sometime.

    Just as an example, I compressed a 453MB (decimal MB since that's the standard for mass storage and I'm too lazy to convert it) BIN+CUE that I had handy:

    Normal, Solid: 315,867,792 bytes

    Normal: 315,867,775 bytes
     
  8. archiver

    archiver New Member

    Since you said please... ok ;)

    Seriously, I do see what you mean and appreciate the correction. Most of the stuff I've archived have been smaller files in a group, so using solid has been a bit of a habit. I'll treat .bin/.cues (and pretty much any large single files) differently.
     
  9. mal

    mal Member

    Isn't that only relevant to rar reconstruction (the second stage) rather than recovery?
     

Share This Page