Bin-cue vs mp3-iso

GO TO ADMIN PANEL > ADD-ONS AND INSTALL VERTIFORO SIDEBAR TO SEE FORUMS AND SIDEBAR

Xai

New Member
Joined
Apr 10, 2002
Messages
127
Points
16
To be more specific, in regards to Saturn games, does ISO-MP3 provide decent quality rips? How big of a difference is there between the two formats? Also, the only difference in quality would be the audio right? Would people prefer BIN-CUE rips over ISO-MP3?
 

ExCyber

Staff member
Joined
Aug 8, 2001
Messages
4,014
Points
36
Age
38
The only substantial advantage provided by ISO/MP3 is that the resulting image is smaller. ISO/MP3 is slightly more difficult to work with and consistently creating a disc layout identical to the original is nearly impossible. Fortunately, most Saturn and Sega CD games don't really care which sector each track starts at, they just read from wherever the track happens to be.

BIN has a couple of notable advantages and one big disadvantage. It is usually more straightforward to burn and provides a copy closer to the original, but it tends to be bigger, particularly on games that have a lot of audio. For games that store all their audio on the data track, or create it with synthesis, MP3 will not provide a significant size advantage. In any case, a bigger image takes up more space on FTP sites and takes longer to download.

It's worth noting that cuesheets are not format-specific, and it's a good idea to include a cuesheet with ISO/MP3 rips to ensure that the resulting copies are as close to the original as is possible with MP3. This also helps eliminate some of the confusion that can arise when attempting to burn ISO/MP3 images.
 

mal

Member
Joined
May 14, 2001
Messages
7,123
Points
36
Age
45
Website
Visit site
To be more specific, in regards to Saturn games, does ISO-MP3 provide decent quality rips? How big of a difference is there between the two formats?
That depends on how well the mp3s are encoded, and how critical your hearing is. I personally don't mind good quality mp3 rips, but some people hate them.

Also, the only difference in quality would be the audio right? Would people prefer BIN-CUE rips over ISO-MP3?
Usually the audio quality is the only difference. However some games are very picky about post gaps and pregaps and a bin/cue rip makes this much easier. Also dual data mode discs tend to be easier to burn as bin/cue.

Which do people prefer? There's a whole spectrum of opinion out there.
 

Xai

New Member
Joined
Apr 10, 2002
Messages
127
Points
16
What's the bitrate used in most saturn rips?
 

Xavier

Mid Boss
Joined
Feb 13, 2002
Messages
639
Points
16
Age
43
Website
oldschool-games.com
Ive gotten some that are 98 .(crap)

128 148 are good

anything over 168 gets to be overkill and after awhile isnt any smaller than the original wav file .

That just my opion , sorry its been awhile since I played around with mp3's so I might have some of the exact numbers confused .
 

MasterAkumaMatata

Staff member
Joined
Apr 18, 2001
Messages
3,300
Points
36
Location
Akuma Island
Website
superakuma5k.homestead.com
Originally posted by Xavier@May 17 2002,08:53

Ive gotten some that are 98 .(crap)

128 148 are good

anything over 168 gets to be overkill and after awhile isnt any smaller than the original wav file .

That just my opion , sorry its been awhile since I played around with mp3's so I might have some of the exact numbers confused .
Here you go: 96, 128, 160 (usually divisible by 16, and in some cases, by 8).

Personally, when I make ISO+MP3 rips, I do 160kbps bit-rate encoding.
 
Top